David Hines (hradzka) wrote,
David Hines

a shootout story

Saw an interesting news story on a police gunfight. Interesting and unusual, not only because it's an NYT article that praises the heroism of the police officer involved in a shootout -- this rarely happens -- but because it does so for the wrong reasons.

Background: NYPD Officer Ferris Jones, a 20-year veteran who collects evidence for the crime lab, was getting her hair done when a 19-year-old man, Winston Cox, entered the salon with a large revolver and demanded money. Once the women in the salon had placed their belongings into his bag, he ordered them into a bathroom in the back and began to ransack the place for more valuables. Jones took their confinement as potentially a very bad sign, and gave her cell phone to the shop owner with an instruction to call 911. Jones then exited the bathroom and identified herself as a police officer, whereupon Winston Cox opened fire on her. Jones returned fire with her off-duty carry piece, which the NYT identifies only as a five-shot revolver, no make or caliber listed (so I'm guessing a Smith & Wesson J-frame). She emptied her gun. This is where the story gets interesting:

One shot knocked the gun from the man’s two-handed grip, piercing his right middle finger and grazing his left hand, according to the police. Another shot hit the lock on the front door, jamming it. The gunman tried to flee, Mr. Browne said, but could not get the door open. Finally, he grabbed his gun, kicked out a lower panel on the door and crawled out. Officer Jones followed him out the door to see which way he was running.

[NYPD Spokesman] Mr. Browne said Officer Jones’s performance was commended at an internal police briefing by Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly, who said that “her reserve under fire was matched only by her marksmanship.”

Terrific job by Officer Jones. No question. The only problem is that the article, and for that matter the NYPD spokesman, makes it sound like Officer Jones shot the gun out of the guy's hands deliberately, and used another bullet to try to lock the guy in, which is Western-serial bullshit. I can see why the NYT wants to promote it, because it promotes an idealized view of what's possible in police violence. Look, Jones was being shot at and she managed to *shoot the gun out of the bad guy's hands!* Cops should do that *all the time!* While Jones was unquestionably heroic, she was heroic in attainably human ways, and the article makes her out to have skills on par with the Lone Ranger.

Folks get their hands shot in gunfights all the time. Unless the other party is a sniper and has a lot of time to aim, it happens by accident. It happens because we tend to look at what is freaking us out, which is usually the other guy's gun, and we tend to shoot at what draws our focus. What you *want* to do is shoot center mass, because that will stop the bad guy much more effectively. Also, you're going to be having an adrenaline dump that makes your accuracy go to hell, so you want a really big target. I really doubt Officer Jones was shooting at the gun or the lock on the door; she was shooting at Winston Cox's center mass, per the dictates of her training, and her adrenaline dump caused her to miss. Despite this, she scored a hit on him with at least one bullet out of her five. With a snubby revolver. Solid work. Winston Cox missed completely with his revolver, a .44 Magnum. From the Times photo, Cox looks to have been carrying a Ruger New Model Super Blackhawk with a five-and-a-half-inch barrel.

Here's everything you need to know about accuracy in a gunfight: two shooters, one a career criminal and one a police officer, trading up to eleven rounds, only one of which hits its intended human target.

Per the NYT and the NYPD, the gunfight took place at a distance of twelve feet.

Originally posted on my DW. | comment count unavailable people have commented there. | Do so yourself, if you like.
Tags: guns

  • what I really did like about THE AVENGERS

    I did not expect that I would come out of it with the two most interesting characters being Hulk and Black Widow. Black Widow got a lot of action and…

  • watched ORPHAN

    Saw the nifty horror flick ORPHAN, and now it's on my list of potential Yuletide requests. Except I'd want a ludicrous sequel/crossover, with Esther…

  • the Scalzi remakes LITTLE FUZZY thing

    Acclaimed SF writer John Scalzi has written and will be publishing a remix/reboot of H. Beam Piper's acclaimed, beloved, Hugo-nominated SF novel…

  • Post a new comment


    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded