David Hines (hradzka) wrote,
David Hines

Rucka and Brubaker

miss_porcupine has posted some links to interviews with Rucka and Brubaker about their various writings. They're great interviews, with a lot of food for thought -- and lots to praise, criticize, and argue with. Especially because these guys are such good writers and know what the hell they're doing.

I think the two most interesting are the interviews having to deal with Gotham Central and Superman. (Some of the content of Rucka's Superman interview makes an interesting compare/contrast with some of Brubaker's about Captain America.) One passage re: Superman:

With Batman, when you get him right, you’ve got him. Batman is such a character that the multiple interpretations of Batman all pretty much work – they can all coexist. Everybody works from Frank Miller’s template and go their own way, but they all know what point they’re starting from. You can write a Batman line five or ten different ways, and it will still read like Batman is saying it.

You can not do that with the Joker, in contrast. The Joker, you have to write spot-on, or he fails. Superman is the same way.

I think that's far more right than wrong -- Superman is harder to write than Batman, for a myriad of reasons -- but I think that going on from there Rucka makes a mistake in defining Superman's essential character too narrowly, and that he does so for reasons that have to do with what Brubaker says he's going to try to avoid in Captain America. And I think that ultimately doesn't serve the character or the material -- or, frankly, the writer. Let alone the audience.

Will post more on this when I have more time.

  • moving stuff update

    Managed to hurt back and leg, and got an eye problem requiring medical attention, which put cramp on ability to pack, which meant I had to cancel…

  • strong backs or suggestions for obtaining same needed, DC-ish

    Folks, a request: I am up at Ma's for a few days (Silver Spring, MD) to load up a moving truck with a bunch of my stuff from her house to drive down…

  • house pictures

    OK, it's taken me a while to get pics sorted, but here you go. PICTURES OF THE HOUSE. At this point, I need to emphasize something: this house…

  • Post a new comment


    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded